Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket both make for pleasant island vacations because of their sun-drenched beaches, stunning scenery, and lovely settlements. These two islands of Cape Cod are significantly different from summer vacation spots in New England, despite the fact that only a few miles of water divide them. You can choose which Island is ideal for you by considering how each one’s unique atmosphere differs from the others. Listed below are some of the main distinctions between Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard that you should consider while making your choice.
Highlights Of Nantucket Vineyard
- The Whaling Museum is a must-see attraction on Nantucket. The island’s ancient mansion, which has been renovated, will appeal to history buffs as well. You’ll also notice that buildings have names, a tradition that dates back to the days when vessels would capsize.
- You could check out Something Natural on Nantucket, a renowned sandwich shop in the area. There is a line out the door, and the bread is freshly made daily on the premises. You must get the lobster salad.
- On Nantucket, Main Street is a mecca for shopping. Visit Murray’s Toggery Shop if you’re looking for a pair of the distinctive Nantucket Red pants. Additionally, there is the ideal beach-themed home decorating shops on these cobblestone alleys.
- With six communities and dimensions of wide Martha’s Vineyard is significantly larger. Even if you could tour the entire area in a day, you’d need more time to thoroughly visit and get a sense of the distinctive character of each village.
- The cost of hotels in Nantucket is on the rise. Day visitors won’t likely notice whether the islands seem more costly because it is only visitable for a short period of time.
Highlights Of Martha’s Vineyard
- With 96 square miles, Martha’s Vineyard is larger than Nantucket by more than two times. There are a plethora of activities to discover and do on Martha’s Vineyard that you can easily fill a week with.
- The island of Martha’s Vineyard is a haven for nature lovers with its undulating hills and jagged cliffs. There are also many ports and beaches at which you can enjoy the day relaxing in the sea air.
- For those seeking to get away from the city, Martha’s Vineyard is a popular destination due to its laid-back attitude and relaxing ambiance. Despite being a popular destination for politicians, entertainers, and celebrities, the atmosphere on the island is peaceful and easygoing.
- There are five golf courses on Martha’s Vineyard, three of which are available to the public and two of that are private. You can sign up for membership at The ancient and royals Chappaquiddick Links or just pay the whole day’s charge.
- There are numerous tall hills and undulating slopes on Martha’s Vineyard. Six communities, each with a distinct personality and a rich history, are also located there.
Martha’s Vineyard Vs Nantucket-The Key Differences
Below, I described to you the major key difference between both vineyards to clarify both vineyards.
Geography And Architecture
The Sound is a triangle-shaped section of the ocean that is bordered by the islands of Nantucket, Martha’s Vineyard, and Cape Cod. However, Martha’s Vineyard’s terrain and culture diverge significantly from those found on Nantucket.
Beaches
The beaches are the primary draws on both Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket. Nantucket barely has 80 miles of coastline compared to 124 miles in Martha’s Vineyard. Both islands’ beaches range in size from little coves with calm waters that are ideal for kids and families to larger coves with rougher waves.
Transportation Options
Both of these honorable mention locations are accessible by plane or sea travel. However, the frequency of transportation is very different. If you want to explore both islands, you might be happy to learn that there’s an interisland ferry that travels during the busiest times and takes one hour.
Cost Of Both Islands
These islands are expensive, there is no doubt about that. Both are home to some of the most expensive properties in the nation, and the majority of the hotels, eateries, and retail establishments are high-end. However, because of its size, Martha’s Vineyard offers a greater variety, which makes it easier to locate affordable lodging and dining options there.
Fog In The Islands
The fog has a hauntingly lovely quality. Both islands receive a lot of it, but in Martha’s Vineyard, the fog typically clears by noon. Go up towards the island and take in the sailboats moored as the sun comes up if you enjoy foggy mornings and bays covered in gray. Everything is shrouded in a mystical blanket that makes for an excellent photo opportunity.
Shops Of Islands
Both Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard are overflowing with charming small enterprises; neither island has many chain eateries or well-known retailers. No matter which of these “sister islands” you choose, you can expect a wonderful time because they are all recognized for drawing artists, writers, and celebrities.
| Properties | Martha Vineyard | Nantucket Vineyard |
| Lodging | 80+ hotels | 5 hotels and 38 inns |
| Restaurants | 80 restaurants | 61 restaurants |
| Beaches | 19 beaches | 23 beaches |
| Golf Courses | 4 golf courses | 3 gold courses |
| Cycling Trails | 44 miles | 32 miles |
Also Read
MYKONOS VS. SANTORINI: THE SUPREME GUIDE FOR CHOOSING THE BEST ONE!
Wrap-Up
Choosing between Nantucket vs. Martha’s Vineyard comes down to your personal taste and vacation style. Both islands have their personal devotees who wouldn’t consider living on the other island! In all honesty, you can not make a wrong decision with either island because both are pretty special.
